appreciator

Someone who appreciates a given thing, especially:

I find, too, that the chance for appreciation [of imaginative literature] is much increased by being the son of an appreciator, and that these boys who now grow up are caught not only years too late, but two or three births too late, to make the best scholars of.

[…] I speak as an appreciator of not just the architecture but the way you have preserved its atmosphere,

Someone who appreciates a given thing, especially:

Let no chicaning intermediate agent but suffered to pass between the manufacturers and the Company’s warehouse-keepers and sorters, except the sworn appreciators and examiners, according to standard samples, secreted from the view, and from every possible communication with the owners.

1794, Review of The Age of Infidelity, in The English Review, Volume 24, p. 124, that respectable collector and appreciator of religious evidence, Archdeacon Paley